How to Recruit Affiliates from Competitor Leaderboards

by | Jul 6, 2026 | Podcast

Your best affiliate prospects are usually hiding in plain sight… on other people’s leaderboards. In this episode, I’m breaking down how to recruit affiliates from competitor leaderboards, including exactly where to find the lists, how to choose the right prospects, and how to reach out in a way that starts real relationships instead of sounding like a spammy pitch.

Click Here for The Written Transcript of This Episode

TEXT ME: +1 (260) 217-4619

 

Don’t Miss An Episode – Subscribe Below

Listen on Apple Podcasts

Listen on Spotify

Listen on YouTube

Listen on Amazon

Email Me New Episodes

Ask a Question for the Show

 

Previous Episodes of The Affiliate Guy

How to Get Affiliates to Plan Their Promotions in Advance

How to Make Your Affiliate Program Stand Out to Affiliates

How to Expand Your Affiliate Program Internationally

The 6 C’s of Elite Affiliate Programs (Part 4)

The 6 C’s of Elite Affiliate Programs (Part 3)

The 6 C’s of Elite Affiliate Programs (Part 2)

How to Recruit Affiliates from Competitor Leaderboards

Today, I’m going to share a little secret with you. It’s something that I’ve used to get awesome affiliates and develop some amazing relationships over the years. I shared it with a client the other day and already she’s used it to get two affiliates who are likely to bring in more than $200,000 in sales. Listen up, because this episode is going to be juicy.  So this is like the epitome of an unplanned podcast episode because we didn’t have it on the plan, we did not have this on our calendar. But I shared this with a client the other day, and as I said at the beginning, she’s used what I’m going to share with you in this episode very quickly.

I mean, we’re talking right before Christmas. I’m recording this right after the new year. So this is like two weeks ago. So this is over Christmas. She landed two affiliates who, based on what I know about these affiliates, I’m pretty confident, I, mean on the very low end, they’re going to bring in between the two of 125,000 in sales.This is a client, just for the record, who last year did less than $600,000 in sales. So to get two affiliates who could potentially be worth a quarter of a million dollars a year. First time she did what I’m teaching in this episode. So if I haven’t, like, I just want to be clear, if that hasn’t made you like, perk up, press pause. Like if you’re in the car and you need to press pause so that you listen to this when you can take notes and actually put this into action.

I don’t know that I’ve ever shared anything. You know, I love to think that, you know, this is our 473rd episode. I love to think I’ve shared some six figure ideas. I, I can promise you, I don’t think I’ve ever shared anything that’s going to make you six figures in, you know, that short of a period of time. I’m not a get rich quick person.All right? That’s not my mo. But this is big. I had to check. I don’t think I’ve ever, I don’t know, maybe I have shared this.So maybe I’ve shared this before. Maybe I haven’t If I have shared it, I’ve shared it kind of in passing. I haven’t shared it in the detail that I shared with our client the other day about this. And so, I’m going to tell you what it is in a second. I’m not going to build this up too much, but again, just to be clear, like, we’re talking.

She just started doing this. She did this with only a handful of people, got two of them to agree to promote her upcoming launch. And I am confident, almost guaranteed. I looked at their numbers. I know their metrics.I know one of them’s promoted some other clients. I am confident this is going to be worth over $200,000. I mean, a 33% increase in revenue over last year. Just boom, like that. So this is huge.All right, so here’s what I had her do. You know, we’re doing a coaching call. She’s one of our clients in your affiliate launch coach. You can find out more about that, by the way@your affiliatelaunchcoach.com and, she was promoting this launch.

She’s promoting, another big launch out there that was happening, actually overlapped with the new year. And she was. She was doing okay. She was in, like, I think she said she was in ninth place. Okay, so not.Not, like, you know, she’s not one of the top three affiliates. She was pushing pretty hard. She was doing pretty good. You know, this was a big deal for her. She’d Never finished top 10 in a launch before in a launch leaderboard as an affiliate.So she’s pretty stoked now. That’s not necessarily, you know, like, you. You don’t have to be in the top 10. We’ll talk about that. Like, you don’t have to be one of the top 10 affiliates.

That’s not necessarily relevant. Just giving you some perspective on where she was. And, you know, so right before Christ, she was like, hey, I’m getting ready to go into open cart after Christmas. You know, I’m promoting this launch. I’m in ninth place right now.She ended up finishing in ninth place. Exactly. You know, she finished right where she was. She was like, I got up to eighth, and then I dropped back to, like, ninth and then 10th and back up to ninth. And she was asking me for some advice as an affiliate, you know, because clearly I, you know, I know what I’m doing on that side, too.She’s like, hey, how do I make more money? You know, Are there any things. I shared a few things with her, and I said, you Know everything I just shared with you, this is a launch where if she did really, really well, like the top affiliate was going to do 75, maybe 100,000 in sales. So we’ll go with a hundred thousand. They’re going to make $40,000.

The Book on Affiliate Management by Matt McWilliams

And she’s probably going to make, you know, if she really busted it, she could top down at 30,000 in sales, so about 12,000, 12,000, 13,000 in commissions. And, you know, she was trending towards about, like, she was gonna probably do, like, you know, $9,000, you know, $10,000. And I told her, I said, I can give you some advice. My advice is gonna help you grow by 20 or 30%. And that’s great.You know, making an extra three, $4,000 is awesome. But if you want me to give you some advice on what’s gonna make the biggest impact on your business, let’s talk about something else. She said, okay, I’m listening. And I was like, okay, let me teach you real quick how to do better on the leaderboard, because what I’m about to share with you will help you. Finishing higher on the leaderboard will help you get affiliates.

Okay. When you follow what I’m about to share with you. So no doubt about it. If you’ve got a, if you’ve got a chance, you know, to finish ninth on the leaderboard, hey, ninth is top 10. That means something.People list, you know, their top 10, their top 20. If, you got a chance to finish in 19th versus not being in the top 20, then, you know, fight to get top 20. Follow what I teach about affiliate marketing. Nothing I shared with her, nothing that I shared with her is something that I haven’t shared inside of. Affiliate Insider Monthly, for example, our membership site.If you want to get a trial of that, by the way, mattmcwilliams.com AIM trial. AIM trial for affiliate Insider Monthly trial. You can get in for a buck, right? It gets you a couple months for a dollar.

And it’s not anything I haven’t shared inside of there. This was not like, monumental things that I’ve never shared with anybody. I told her, hey, do you have a bonus package? She’s like, yeah. And I said, okay, let’s tweak that a little bit.Let’s, let’s add this, but let’s do this to make, you know, that’ll get a little bit more traction. And I said, here, I want you to add this email at this time. You know, on the last day, I told her to do this. I said, hey, reach out to the person who’s, you know, running the launch, why don’t you do a live with them? Go live on the second to last day or the last day.Did a few things to tweak her promotion that helped her. She said later, she’s like, you know, I looked at the numbers. There’s. There’s no way I would have finished in 11th place, which would have sucked. You know, 11th place is terrible compared to ninth, even though it’s only two spots.

It’s kind of like in. I was listening to a guy earlier, he’s a marathon runner, and he’s talking about, like, top 10 is what get. You know, when he was running is what got paid. And he’s like, I kept finishing in 11th or 12th, and he was like, there’s nothing else I could do, you know, so he’s. So he finally realized that he either needed to completely change his training so that he could become more professional and actually make money doing it, or he just needed to, like, you know, he needed to slow down.And, Because who cares if you finish in 12th or 23rd? You know, he was like, it wasn’t a pride thing. He was like, it really was a money thing. So he beefed up his training and he became, you know, he’s one of the top, like, 10 marathoners in. In the country right now.

So now he’s actually making money doing it, which can justify the time spent. So, yeah, 11th would be terrible. So I gave her some tips on the affiliate side, and that plays a role in what m. I’m about to share with you, because the higher she finished, well, the better it looked when she did this thing. And so what I said to her, I said, the thing that’s going to move the needle the Most.Yeah, extra $4,000. a little bit of prestige. It’s great. You learn a little bit about some promotional stuff. I spent 15 minutes helping her on the affiliate side, maybe 20.Shared some basic stuff with her. She and her team implemented it. They made more money. That’s awesome. But I said, number one, I want you to engage with the other affiliates in the Facebook group and privately.

So that’s number one. All right. We’re talking about how to use leaderboards to find affiliates. These other companies, the ones that you’re promoting as an affiliate, they are publishing a list of their top affiliates. They are handing them to you on a silver platter.They are saying to you, hey, affiliate, do you want to know who our other top affiliates are? Ding, ding, ding. So I said, I want you to engage with them, congratulate them when somebody moves up three spots on the leaderboard overnight, put a comment on the Facebook post, dm somebody who passes you and just, you know, kind of give a little playful trash talk or just say, hey, I know, you know, I noticed, you know, we’re like, we’re right there together on the leaderboard. I’d love to connect sometime. You know, we don’t really know.

I’ve seen you around, don’t know who, you know, blah, blah. Just be a human being, right? There’s no, oh, you got to craft this message perfectly, right? No, this is just being a good human being. So, hey, I’d love to connect sometime.And I’ve talked about this before, right? You know, some of my best friends in the online marketing world, we connected because of affiliate leaderboards. But here’s the key. Number one, she engaged with them. She engaged with the people on the leaderboard, not just the top people.As the ninth place affiliate, she had a little bit of credibility. She had some street cred to, to be able to reach out to the top three and be like, hey, I want to get to know you better. But she didn’t just do that. And we’ll talk about in a minute what to do if you’re not in the top 10, that’s fine. But she reached out to people who were in 15th, 20th, 25th place.

Need help activating your affiliates? Use my proven email templates for getting inactive affiliates in the game and making sales! Get them here!

affiliate activation email templates

She even reached out to everyone that they posted and said, hey, this person made their first sale today. She congratulated them. I asked her afterwards. I was like, how much time did you spend? You’re like three minutes a day.I just did it when I was regularly checking into Facebook. I didn’t specifically set aside time. I did it once a day for. For about three minutes. I took a couple of the posts and I engaged with them.She made sure that she was seen in that Facebook group. She would. When the affiliate manager would do. Because the affiliate manager is, for lack of a better term, a disciple of mine. I trained this affiliate manager so he posts some of the same stuff that I would post.And he would post tips in the Facebook group. She’d say thanks and then offer a thoughtful response to it. So, for instance, this affiliate manager posted a, tip about how to use swipe copy like the one that we’ve posted before and many times every launch. And this client of ours thanked the affiliate manager and said, yeah, whatever you suggested in number three, you know, you know, number three is really important. Here’s how we’ve done it.

And then people responded to her saying, oh, thanks so much. Now I get it. I didn’t understand what he said. Now I get it. Blah, blah, blah, right?So she engaged in the group and became kind of an expert in the group. She became someone that everybody recognized three minutes a day for a couple of weeks. I mean, literally less than one hour of her time. So that was step number one. One of those two affiliates reached out to her, saw her in there quite a bit and reached out to her.So you could easily argue that less than one hour of engagement in that group is going to bring in 50 to $100,000 a year for her business. Because they reached out to her, she didn’t have to do part two or three about what I’m about to share. That’s pretty cool. That’s a good ROI. I don’t know about you.

I don’t make 50 to $100,000 in an hour. All right? I consider myself to be highly paid for what I do, fairly paid for what I do, and I don’t make 50 to $100,000 an hour. And so if you can find something I can spend one hour doing over the course of two weeks that is virtually guaranteed potentially to bring in that kind of money, I will do it all day long. And I do do this all day long.It’s just unfortunately, I can’t do it 40 hours a week or I would. So that said, hugely, hugely profitable for her in that regard. The second thing she did, like I said, so she engaged in the group. She engaged privately with them, on Facebook. Second thing she did is after the launch when they published their final leaderboard via email.

That is not in the Facebook group, but I’m counting that in the Facebook group. So she was congratulating people. She was trash talking with people. She’d never done any of that before, by the way she responded. She clicked reply to the final leaderboard message, but made the to field be anybody that she wanted to engage with.So anybody in the top, like 30. She reached out to him and said, hey, you know, congratulations. Winning. Congratulations on fifth place. Looks like you beat me.Hey, I’d love to connect. Within a week, she had scheduled like half a dozen calls. She’s got more on the docket later, but she scheduled like six or seven right away. One of those people had already reached out to her, became one of those calls. One of them was like, boom, I’m in.Your launch sounds perfect. I am in, all in. I’m like, I’m in to win. I’m in it to win it. You know, let’s do something magical together, right?

So you reach out to those people and you just say, hey, congratulations, or great job, or I loved watching, you know, hey, I subscribed to your, email list. I loved watching what you were doing. I love that Facebook Live that you did. That’s part three is start following them and engage with them on other levels. Right?But what she did, she took another couple of minutes and she followed the people who were on the leaderboard. She friended them on Facebook and she saw how they were promoting. And then she would say, oh, I love that Facebook Live that you did. Or I love the email that you sent. I love the such and such that you did.

I love the bonus that you put together. I shared with her the story of how I used to joke, with Ray Edwards about how like, dude, your bonuses are so good. I’m going to buy through your link. Even though I’m an affiliate. She used that line on somebody else.You know, she gave her the idea. She was being honest. She’s like, your bonus package. I have bonus package envy. Your bonus package is so amazing.That started a conversation. They haven’t. That I know of. They haven’t agreed to work together yet or do anything together yet. But I think it’s going to be a profitable relationship for her.

I’ve used this so many times. I’m telling you, it works. Now you might be thinking, okay, this works. If you’re in the top 10 DOE, your client is in ninth place in a multi million dollar affiliate launch. Of course she gets to go and be like, hey, number five affiliate.I’m somebody, and you’re somebody. We should. Yeah, that’s. This only works, right if you’re one of the top 10. That’s not right.If you’re in 30th place, don’t reach out to the number one affiliate. All right? Work your way up. Hey, maybe you’re on the, others on the leaderboard or people who’ve also made sales. You know, I’ve run affiliate launches where, you know, 294 affiliates have made sales.We ran one last year. Over 450 affiliates made a sale. You might be in 373rd place, but you’re in there. You’re in the Facebook group, you’re engaging, people are seeing you, you’re celebrating that you made a few sales. Okay?

If you are ready to take your business to the next level and start an affiliate program, start with my free report, Your First 100 Affiliates. This report takes nearly two decades of experience, trial and error, and lessons learned about finding top affiliates in nearly every conceivable niche and puts them all into one report. Grab your copy here!

You’re kind of legit. I’d, like, maybe like to probably get to know you a little bit better, see if we can do Some business together. So you reach out to some of those people who are also in the also made sales list. If you’re in 53rd place, you reach out to number 30 through number whatever. Right.Are you going to make $200,000 off of two affiliates? No. But could you make 40 or $50,000 off of 10 affiliates? Yes, absolutely could. And then guess what?Now you do that, your list grows. The next affiliate promotion you do, instead of being in 184th place, you’re in 75th place and you’re reaching out to the 50th to the hundredth affiliates. And now the next time you’re in 30th place and you’re reaching out to the top, you know, to the 11th through 5th. And then the next time you’re in the top 10, baby, you work your way up. So number one, engage in the group.

Number two. I kind of got number two and number three mixed up. Number two would be follow them, get on their list, get to know them, get to know their content and comment on that content. Connect with them that way. And then third, send that email.Very simple email. You know, you just reply to the final leaderboard and you just say, great job, congratulations. One year I went into Canva and I made images. It was like, congratulations on your performance in such and such launch. I’m like, well, that was overkill.A couple sentences would have sufficed. Don’t say, I’d love to get, you know, at that point, don’t be like, hey, I’d love to connect. No, just leave it at that. Just leave it at that. Put the ball in their court.

They will reply and say stuff back to you that you’ll be amazed. And it’s a numbers game. You do this 20 times per launch, you’ll get one or two, three partners each time. You do that over the course of 10 launches and you’ve got 30 really, really good partners. So listen, if you got any questions about this or anything else, shoot me a text, you know, 2602-1746-1926-0217-4619 I’d love to connect with you that way.Make sure you subscribe because you do not want to miss the next episode. I’m going to share with you what and how to communicate to your affiliates. So what to communicate to your affiliates and how to communicate to them. What do you actually communicate to them? When do you communicate with them?

and how do you communicate with them? Three critical questions that I’m going to answer in the next episode. So make sure you click that subscribe button if you haven’t yet so you don’t miss that and I will see you then. Thank you so much for listening today. Remember to check out all of our deep dives into affiliate marketing at TheAffiliateGuide TV, and if you have a question, ask it at AskTheAffiliateGuide.com who knows, maybe you even be featured on an upcoming episode. And lastly, if you haven’t yet, make sure to leave a rating and replace review wherever you’re listening to this episode.